A very difficult issue...
Hi friends from ES2007S if you are reading this I’m glad you are and I really need your help. I have a huge moral and ethics situation here that I cannot resolve. I want to hear from as many people as possible before I decide what to do tomorrow morning.
A little background…
I’ve been working in a design project which is a huge project for mechanical engineering students which spans across 2 semesters. Throughout the process I have made lots of great friends in the group. Everyone in there had great personality and I treasure all the friendships that were forged.
Last semester I had no qualms with agreeing to a common peer review because everybody did a fair amount of work. However in this semester everything changed. Different people involved themselves with different tasks and there were people in the group who contributed negligibly. Being the main designer for 2 sub systems (lighting and dashboard display of a car) had to single-handedly do all the wiring connections and connections. I could not delegate the tasks with my teammates since the systems were very complex and would take a long time to explain. On top of that since I’m only soldering 1 circuit board there is no way others could help me. I’m not upset with the fact that I had much more to do than my teammates and some of them helped me as far as they could and I’m very appreciative.
The problem…
Peer evaluation. It comes in a form a table where you need to rank everyone in the group and also give a grade to individual aspects of in terms of contribution, attitude and all. Although not openly agreed, everyone had the common understanding that peer evaluation will be done together with everyone writing the same thing similar to what we did that last semester.
I personally felt that this was really unfair because there were people who contributed much less than others. I’m not saying that I have done the most and there were certainly people who did more than me. A combined peer evaluation will simply not reflect the extra commitment and effort. The professor was not there to monitor and keep track of individual contributions and peer evaluation is one of the ways that he could have a gauge. Another grading venue which the professor will judge is through the log book which we had to submit. For my logbook I logged everything about the two sub-systems that I did and nothing more. However there are teammates who wrote about every system in the project in which some they did not even participate. A third venue of evaluation would be the presentation that we gave. But since everyone had to have something to present I had to give up 1 subsystem to another teammate.
The concern…
I’m really concerned over how the professors would have valued the amount of work that was invested by me. In all three aspects of individual grading, none reflects the fact that I’ve done a lot. After all the sweat, doing yoga in a tight compartment and soldering the millions of points that needed soldering, I really wanted to be appreciated. The only chance I have now is peer evaluation.
The Questions…
If you are in my situation
Do you message the whole group telling them that you are uncomfortable with the group decided peer evaluation?
Would you have just conformed to the crowd and go with the group decided peer evaluation?
OR
Would you have submitted an honest peer review that you have filled in to how you feel? There is no way that anyone in the team will find out.
By submitting an honest peer review is it very unethical and immoral?
If you are the professor and you realize that only 1 person out of the 8 has a peer evaluation would you mark him down?
On top of that would you even consider his ranking in the peer review since he was the only one which might reflect the fact that he might not be a team player?
Do you think that emailing the professor directly to tell the group to do the peer evaluation individually would be a good idea?
To Conclude…
I’m really in a dilemma right now. On one hand I value these friends I made and on the other it is my grades that are in concerned. I really don’t think I can accept it if I do not get rewarded for all the effort I put into this project. Am I overvaluing grades and downplaying friendship? Please give me your honest feedback and what you would do in my situation as it would influence my course of action.
Thanks in advance.